Which Gemstones Are Right for Your Stud Earrings?

There’s a reason studs are a jewellery staple: they just make sense. No fuss, no drama, and they’ll carry you from morning meetings to dinner out without missing a beat.

Add gemstones, and you’ve got something even better: earrings that aren’t just pretty, but personal. Diamonds bring that classic polish, while colourful stones feel a bit more playful or sentimental. The beauty of it all? You get to decide which feels right for you. And if you’re not sure, we’ll walk you through it.

Why Gemstone Selection Is Key for Stud Earrings

Stud earrings are one of those little things that make a big difference. They don’t dangle or move about; they just sit there quietly, but right where people notice. The stone you go for changes the whole mood. 

Diamonds are always elegant, emeralds feel strong and confident, and other gems each bring their own energy. It’s not just about what matches your clothes. It’s about what works for you day to day, and what feels right against your skin.

That’s why the right studs can be magic. They can turn a plain tee into something polished, or make a dress look instantly sharper.

If you want to get into the details, our guide Stud Earrings: Shapes, Styles, and Backs Explained covers everything.

How Birthstones, Trends, and Outfit Matching Influence Choice

The nice thing about gemstone earrings is that they can mean something as well as look good. Birthstones are a perfect starting point; they add that bit of personal touch and make your studs feel more special. Stylewise, it’s all about colour and creativity right now.

Of course, fashion has its say too. Celebrities are big on mixing things up, wearing different stones in each ear or stacking colourful studs together. That’s rubbed off on the rest of us, making bold colours more exciting to wear. And then there’s the simple question of outfits: the right gemstone can either blend beautifully with your look or stand out in a way that really turns heads.

Birthstone Inspirations

January – Garnet

The deep red is bold yet comforting, perfect for winter.

February – Amethyst

Purple with a soothing vibe, looks gorgeous in white gold.

March – Aquamarine

Fresh, clear blue, easy-going and full of cool energy.

April – Diamond

The no-brainer: diamonds match absolutely everything.

May – Emerald

Green that feels rich, striking, and seriously classy.

June – Pearl or Alexandrite

Pearls for timeless grace, Alexandrite for a clever touch of magic.

July – Ruby

Confident and fiery. You can’t miss them.

August – Peridot

Playful, zesty green with a summery feel.

September – Sapphire

Dark blue that’s sleek, stylish, and office-to-evening ready.

October – Opal or Tourmaline

Opals shimmer mysteriously; tourmalines keep things colourful.

November – Topaz or Citrine

Glowing golden shades that feel like autumn sunshine.

December – Turquoise or Tanzanite

Choose between bright turquoise or moody violet-blue, both stunning.

Celebrity Trends and Style Influences

We often think of gemstone studs as traditional, but they’ve taken on a whole new personality lately. Celebrities have shown us the possibilities: mixing colours, stacking stones, and layering piercings for fresh, modern looks.

The best part? There’s no “right” way to wear them. Your studs can be subtle, bold, or anywhere in between; it’s completely your call. It's like Margot Robbie wearing a classic diamond stud but also Rita Ora wearing a beautiful, fierce ruby stud. 

For a bit of styling inspiration, you might enjoy our Complete Guide to Stud Earrings: Styles & Tips.

Combining Colours and Stones

The fun of gemstone studs is that you don’t have to keep them identical. Try mixing things around.

Think of jewellery similar to personalities. Sapphire with diamond? Effortlessly refined, like someone who always looks put-together. Amethyst with turquoise? That’s your playful friend who lights up the room. If the colours clash, it adds a spark; if they’re closer in tone, it feels smoother, more intentional. And shapes? Well, mix a circle with a square, say emerald and ruby, and suddenly your earrings have their own little story.

Matching Gemstones to Outfits

The simplest way to match gemstone earrings? Your outfit is the decider. Wearing something neutral? Black, white, or beige? Diamonds and sapphires will do the job, pulling everything together to create a subtle, classy look.  If you’re craving colour, emerald or lapis can do the job without trying too hard.

Now, when your clothes are already loud (bright pinks, oranges, that sort of thing), it’s fun to lean into it. Turquoise paired withpink looks incredible, and peridot with orange is surprisingly good. 

Big night out? Rich stones like rubies or emeralds never miss. For a normal Tuesday, though, garnet or citrine is simple, pretty, and not over the top.

Top Stud Earrings for Every Style

Your earrings don’t need to stick to one mood. Gemstones can shift in response to your emotions on a given day. There isn’t a “one-size-fits-all” choice, but here are a few go-to favourites:

Everyday wear? You can’t go wrong with diamond or pearl studs. They go with literally everything.

Want a bold moment? Rubies or emeralds will never let you blend into the background.
Like to set trends? Try mixing or stacking different stones. Think turquoise paired with amethyst. It’s effortlessly cool.

Dressing up? Sapphire or diamond studs always bring instant polish.

Feeling playful? Peridot, topaz, and tourmaline add that pop of colour that makes an outfit feel fresh.

Other Considerations in Choosing Gemstones

There’s a reason gemstones have stuck around for centuries. Each gemstone tells something. Like how ruby is said to be fierce, sapphire stands for wisdom, and emerald reflects growth. How beautiful is it? That when you wear a gemstone earring, it’s not just a pretty stone, but you also represent its value. 

Worth knowing too: some stones are tougher. Diamonds, sapphires, rubies, safe bets for daily wear. Pearls or opals, though, they’ll thank you for a bit of extra care.

And don’t underestimate the importance of skin tone. Warm undertones usually glow with citrine, garnet, and gold. Cooler undertones? They come alive with sapphire, amethyst, and white gold.

Conclusion

When it comes to gemstone studs, there’s no formula. You just follow what feels good.

Want something bright and cheerful? Go for it. Feeling classic and understated? That works too. The fun part is in trying different combos until one just clicks. Take your time with it. The right pair will feel like they belong.

When you’re ready, Argent & Asher has a collection designed for exactly that moment.